Switch Synology Surveillance Station to Dahua NVR?

[blakehaas]

I’ve been on Synology Surveillance Station for a while. It works, but mobile access is inconsistent, sometimes the app loads instantly, other times it takes ~50 seconds. My setup is solid (enterprise 4TB SSD for surveillance, Tailscale VPN, 1 Gb network), so I suspect Synology’s software.

Current gear

• 4 × EmpireTech 4K Color cameras (one is the EmpireTech T180)
• Storage: enterprise 4TB SSD
• Remote: Tailscale VPN over 1 Gb

Considering

• A high-end Dahua NVR

What I’m looking for

• Fast, reliable mobile access (most usage is via phone; I’ll use the NVR UI only for deeper reviews)
• DMSS app: live view seems quick in my testing—how good is playback scrubbing and timeline navigation? Any lag or crashes?
• Overall reliability/stability of Dahua NVRs day-to-day
• Bonus: Can I add animal detection overnight on the backyard cam? The T180 only offers person detection—any Dahua/NVR-side analytics that can help?

Appreciate any real-world experiences or model recommendations.

 

[bigredfish]

Are you sure your app problem isnt something else? Apps and connectivity can be tricky to troubleshoot and I find 9 out of 10 folks who complain about the app connectivity find it to be something other than the app

I'm big on the current Dahua ecosystem, the newer NVR's are quite good and the app for me is spectacular. That said, if you're in an area wtih shit connectivity or connecting to a shit P2P server, it wont work as well and it still wont be the App's fault.

The current DMSS app now that I've learned it*, is the best version by far. (*surprising how many people blame an app until we find they havent taken the time to learn it)
Yes very quick to load cameras, and playback is very simplified being a button at the bottom of the live view. Mine loads instantaneously /or within 1 second, very quick
Scrubbing works great, choose all and use the time line (its a smaller screen than the PC so yeah its trickier than a big screen, but it works very well). Or choose just certain types of events on that same screen, very easy to use. I dont recall a single crash with this version I updated in January and I use it daily.

Dahua NVR is about as reliable as things come. I just dont even think about it.

I dont have the newest AI NVR so can't say about adding Animal detection to a camera that doesn't have it?


Recommend these

EmpireTech NVR16CH-16P-2AI 16 Channels 1U 16PoE 2HDD Network Video Rec

Multiple decoding formats Support AcuPick with Max. 16-Channel Support N+M cluster AI by recorder AI by camera Security baseline 2.3

empiretech01.com

a little more horsepower and more AI functions by Recorder

EmpireTech NVR5216-16P-EI2 16CH 1U 16PoE 2HDDs WizSense Network Video

Shipping to the United States takes 2 weeks, expedited shipping is not available Max. decoding capability: 40 × 1080p@30 fps or 10 × 8MP@30 fps. Supports IP cameras with a resolution up to 32 MP. Supports 8K HDMI output. AI by Recorder supports 4-channel face detection and recognition, up to 20...

empiretech01.com

 

[blakehaas]

Are you sure your app problem isnt something else? Apps and connectivity can be tricky to troubleshoot and I find 9 out of 10 folks who complain about the app connectivity find it to be something other than the app

I have troubleshooted the problem for a long time. This is not a mobile connectivity issue, I'm talking about on wifi with full 1gb speeds.
It's as if the session times out or something. It's just inconvenient when I want to see what's happening and I can't see any cameras and by the time it loads, everything is done.

88% of the time it works great, but the times that it fails me is the most important times.

 

[Jamesboag304]

Appreciate any real-world experiences or model recommendations.

Just gone through this exact process this weekend, I too was having issues with surveillance station and have always to some degree, finally bit the bullet and purchased an NVR (top one of the 2 mentioned above).

I haven’t setup the remote access via the P2P cloud as I’d prefer to keep my video streams not running through a companies servers, I have setup via IP and wireguard VPN. There is some mixed information re alerts when running this arrangement, but I can confirm I receive mobile alerts without the VPN being connected when I am away from home.

I’m still fine tuning the detection side of things, I run only intrusion and tripwire with object detection to reduce false alarms as much as possible.

Configuration is a bit of a PITA initially as there a lot of setup options for notification’s, schedules by event type etc.

Te app is not as polished as surveillance station but for the quick and reliable opening of streams I’ll live with it, from my interaction with it a few years ago it has come a long way.

I also like having the option of being able to connect this to a monitor which wasn’t easily achievable on the synology without having a PC running.

I have this NVR in my server rack and have a cat to HDMI converter to get the image the 10m to my TV set using existing cabling.

I’m no guru with this setup so it’s very much a work in progress until I get it dialled in but definitely do not have any regrets.

If you require any further info or have any queries, feel free to reply or DM me and I’ll assist if I can.

 

[blakehaas]

Just gone through this exact process this weekend, I too was having issues with surveillance station and have always to some degree, finally bit the bullet and purchased an NVR (top one of the 2 mentioned above).

I haven’t setup the remote access via the P2P cloud as I’d prefer to keep my video streams not running through a companies servers, I have setup via IP and wireguard VPN. There is some mixed information re alerts when running this arrangement, but I can confirm I receive mobile alerts without the VPN being connected when I am away from home.

I’m still fine tuning the detection side of things, I run only intrusion and tripwire with object detection to reduce false alarms as much as possible.

Configuration is a bit of a PITA initially as there a lot of setup options for notification’s, schedules by event type etc.

Te app is not as polished as surveillance station but for the quick and reliable opening of streams I’ll live with it, from my interaction with it a few years ago it has come a long way.

I also like having the option of being able to connect this to a monitor which wasn’t easily achievable on the synology without having a PC running.

I have this NVR in my server rack and have a cat to HDMI converter to get the image the 10m to my TV set using existing cabling.

I’m no guru with this setup so it’s very much a work in progress until I get it dialled in but definitely do not have any regrets.

If you require any further info or have any queries, feel free to reply or DM me and I’ll assist if I can.

Thanks for the information! This is what i was looking for.
I wish there were more reviews with the mobile apps on these NVR's. Sometimes you just have to dive in your self!

I picked up a NVR5216-16P-EI2 and will pair it with a 4tb enterprise samsung ssd for best perf.
I am hoping that it works out great.